The Buffalo Bills have proven themselves as one of the most consistently competitive teams in the AFC in recent years. With a star quarterback in Josh Allen and a solid defense, the Bills’ expectations have been sky-high. But despite these accolades, there are still significant questions that need answering as they head into a critical matchup against the New York Jets in Week 17.
As much as the Bills’ potential has been on full display, this team is far from perfect, and the looming Jets game could be the true test of whether Buffalo is ready to contend for a Super Bowl. Here are three key questions that will define Buffalo’s trajectory heading into this crucial matchup.
1. Is Josh Allen Really an Elite QB?
Josh Allen is undoubtedly one of the most physically gifted quarterbacks in the NFL, but when it comes to the big moments, he’s been far from flawless. Yes, he can make jaw-dropping throws, rush for 100 yards, and lead the offense down the field with ease, but there is a lingering issue with his inconsistency. Against elite defenses and in pressure-packed games, Allen has often faltered with untimely interceptions, poor decision-making, and his inability to stay composed under duress.
While Allen’s highs are breathtaking, his lows are equally damaging. The Bills’ playoff hopes may hinge on Allen’s ability to rise to the occasion and prove he’s more than just a highlight reel. With the Jets’ defense ranked among the best in the league, this upcoming game will be a crucial test of Allen’s growth and maturity as a franchise QB. Can he perform when the stakes are highest, or will he continue to struggle in clutch situations?
2. Can the Bills’ Offense Establish Consistency?
While Allen gets most of the attention, the Bills’ offense as a whole is far from perfect. The rushing attack, in particular, has been underwhelming this season. Whether it’s injuries, lack of execution, or poor game plans, Buffalo has failed to establish a reliable ground game. This has put more pressure on Allen to do everything, resulting in more mistakes than the team can afford.
In a playoff-caliber offense, a balanced attack is essential. The Bills have seen flashes of a productive running game, particularly with James Cook and the occasional spark from veteran Latavius Murray, but these performances have been inconsistent at best. Heading into the Jets game, it will be critical for Buffalo to prove they can run the ball effectively to complement their passing game. A lack of balance only puts more strain on Allen and the offensive line, leading to predictability and, often, failure.
3. Will the Defense Show Up When It Matters Most?
While the Bills’ defense has been formidable for much of the season, there are areas of concern. The defense has struggled with tackling at times, allowed big plays, and faltered in critical moments, particularly in close games. Against high-caliber quarterbacks and potent offenses, the defense has shown vulnerability, and that’s something that needs to be addressed before the postseason.
The Jets, while inconsistent on offense, still have talent in Zach Wilson and explosive players like Garrett Wilson and Breece Hall. If the Bills’ defense doesn’t show up and put the game away early, they could find themselves in a dogfight with an unpredictable Jets squad. This game will be a litmus test for whether the defense can actually step up in the clutch and prove it’s championship caliber, or if they’ll be exposed in high-pressure situations.
Conclusion
The Buffalo Bills are undeniably talented, but as they look toward a postseason run, they still have plenty to prove. Josh Allen must continue to develop his consistency, the offense must find balance, and the defense needs to step up in crucial moments. If they can’t answer these questions heading into their game against the Jets, the Bills risk entering the playoffs as a team with unfulfilled potential, destined to fall short once again.
With everything on the line, the game against the Jets may ultimately reveal whether the Bills have truly taken the next step or if they remain a team still searching for answers.