As the Alabama Crimson Tide prepares for another season of high expectations, a glaring question remains in the air: does Alabama have an answer at the offensive tackle positions? Given the program’s history of elite offensive lines, it is somewhat unthinkable that the answer would be anything but a resounding “yes.” Yet, as we delve deeper into the current roster and offensive line situation, there’s reason to question whether Alabama’s usual dominance in the trenches is in jeopardy.
A Legacy of Excellence
Under Nick Saban, Alabama football has been synonymous with powerful, NFL-caliber offensive lines. Over the years, players like Andre Smith, Cam Robinson, and Jonah Williams have set the standard for the position, making Alabama’s line a crucial component of their overall success. The offensive tackle spots, in particular, have been a place where top-tier talent is expected to dominate and serve as a foundation for the running game and pass protection.
However, Alabama’s offensive line has shown some signs of weakness in recent seasons. While they’ve remained a solid unit overall, some cracks have begun to appear, particularly at the tackle spots. The departure of star tackle Evan Neal, a top draft pick for the New York Giants, left a significant void at one of the most important positions on the field.
The 2024 Depth Chart: A Cause for Concern?
Entering the 2024 season, the Tide’s offensive tackle positions are still in flux. While they have solid candidates to fill these spots, there’s no clear, proven star waiting to take over. J.C. Latham, once heralded as a future first-round pick, has shown flashes of brilliance, but hasn’t yet consistently lived up to the hype expected of him. His development is crucial—if he doesn’t take that next step, Alabama’s offensive line could struggle to find its rhythm.
On the other side, players like Tyler Booker and true freshman Kadyn Proctor—an elite recruit—have potential but lack the experience that typically defines Alabama’s starting tackles. Proctor, in particular, will face the daunting task of adjusting to the rigors of the SEC and proving himself against some of the toughest defensive lines in the country.
The lack of proven experience at these key positions raises questions about how Alabama’s offensive line will perform, especially against elite defensive units. Teams like Georgia, LSU, and Texas A&M have all been known to bring pressure and disrupt opposing offenses, and without dominant play at tackle, Alabama could find itself vulnerable on both running plays and passing downs.
Scheme and Coaching: Can They Make Up for the Talent Gap?
While it’s true that Alabama’s offensive line coaching is second to none, with legendary coach Kyle Flood in charge, there’s only so much that can be done when the talent isn’t up to par. Alabama’s offensive line has often been able to overcome deficiencies in individual talent through superior coaching and excellent schemes. However, in a world where defensive coordinators are getting smarter and more creative, relying solely on coaching to compensate for weaknesses might not be enough.
The combination of offensive line instability and the loss of experienced players could make it difficult for the Tide to dominate in the same way they have in years past. Can they develop enough cohesion to establish a consistent run game? Can they protect the quarterback—whether it’s Jalen Milroe or a new starter—long enough to execute the explosive passing game that’s expected from the Alabama offense?
The Stakes are High
Alabama’s offensive line has historically been a cornerstone of its dynasty, but in 2024, the stakes are higher than ever. With questions surrounding the tackle positions, the success of the team may rest on the shoulders of younger players with little to no starting experience. If they can step up and find chemistry quickly, Alabama could again be in the conversation for the national championship. But if the offensive tackle positions prove to be a weakness, it could derail not only the offense but the entire 2024 season.
The truth is, Alabama’s reputation for dominant offensive line play is on the line. If they cannot solve the puzzle at the tackle positions, they may find themselves playing catch-up in a conference that has become increasingly competitive. The question now is whether the Crimson Tide has the depth and the development necessary to ensure that their offensive line, once a hallmark of their championship pedigree, doesn’t become a liability.
If the answers to these questions aren’t found soon, Alabama’s supremacy in the trenches might just be a thing of the past.