As the NBA trade deadline looms, the New York Knicks find themselves in an all-too-familiar position—on the cusp of contention but lacking the extra firepower to make a deep playoff run. With Julius Randle, Jalen Brunson, and RJ Barrett forming a solid core, the Knicks must make tough decisions about their supporting cast. One name that stands out in trade discussions is Mitchell Robinson. While Robinson has been a defensive anchor for New York, his limitations on offense and injury concerns beg the question: is it time for the Knicks to trade him and maximize his value before the NBA deadline?
The Case for Trading Mitchell Robinson
1. Injury Concerns and Durability Issues
Robinson’s career has been plagued by injuries, including foot and hand problems that have sidelined him for significant stretches. While he’s shown flashes of dominance when healthy, his durability remains a major concern for a team looking to build long-term success. Relying on a player with such a history can be a gamble, especially for a franchise seeking stability.
2. Offensive Limitations
Robinson’s offensive game remains one-dimensional. While he excels at rim-running and putbacks, his lack of a jump shot or post moves makes him a liability in modern NBA offenses. Opponents can exploit his inability to stretch the floor, clogging the lane and limiting spacing for the Knicks’ primary scorers. Trading Robinson for a more versatile big man or complementary scorer could unlock new dimensions in the Knicks’ offense.
3. Rising Trade Value
Despite his flaws, Robinson is an attractive trade asset. His elite shot-blocking, rebounding, and ability to protect the rim are highly valued around the league. Teams in need of a defensive anchor or a high-energy big man could be willing to part with assets that align better with the Knicks’ current timeline and play style.
Potential Trade Scenarios
1. Robinson for a Stretch Big
One possibility is trading Robinson to a team in need of defense in exchange for a big man who can space the floor. A team like the Indiana Pacers, with Myles Turner, or the Toronto Raptors, with a player like Chris Boucher, could present interesting options. Both provide rim protection while adding a reliable three-point shot, addressing a critical need for New York.
2. Package Deal for a Star
The Knicks could use Robinson as part of a larger trade package to acquire a star player. For example, teams like the Chicago Bulls (with Zach LaVine potentially on the block) or the Toronto Raptors (if Pascal Siakam becomes available) might entertain a deal where Robinson is paired with draft picks and other assets.
3. Rebuild Depth with Draft Picks
If the Knicks want to prioritize long-term flexibility, trading Robinson for young players or future draft capital could be a smart move. Teams like the San Antonio Spurs, who are rebuilding but need a defensive presence, might give up valuable picks or young prospects to acquire him.
The Risks of Trading Robinson
Of course, trading Robinson isn’t without its downsides. His elite rim protection and ability to anchor a defense are difficult to replace. Additionally, his team-friendly contract ($15 million annually through 2026) makes him a cost-effective option at center. Trading him would also put more pressure on Isaiah Hartenstein and Jericho Sims to fill the void, which could backfire if they fail to rise to the occasion.
The Verdict
The Knicks are at a crossroads. Trading Mitchell Robinson before the NBA deadline is a bold move, but it could be the key to unlocking their full potential. By targeting players who complement their core and address their offensive weaknesses, the Knicks can position themselves as legitimate contenders in the Eastern Conference. However, if they choose to hold onto Robinson, they must hope his health and offensive game can improve to justify keeping him long-term.
Ultimately, the Knicks’ front office must decide: is Mitchell