In a move that’s raising eyebrows across the NFL, the Arizona Cardinals have signed running back Michael Carter to a contract extending through the 2025 season. The decision has sparked debate among fans and analysts alike, with many questioning whether this signing is a strategic play or a sign of desperation for a struggling franchise.
A Closer Look at Michael Carter’s Journey
Michael Carter, a fourth-round pick in the 2021 NFL Draft by the New York Jets, entered the league with high expectations following a standout college career at North Carolina. His rookie season showed promise, with Carter rushing for 639 yards and four touchdowns despite playing behind a struggling offensive line. However, his production dipped in the following seasons due to injuries and competition in the Jets’ crowded backfield.
After being waived by the Jets, Carter found himself on the Cardinals’ radar. Arizona, dealing with depth issues at the running back position and seeking offensive consistency, saw an opportunity to take a chance on a player with untapped potential.
Arizona’s Risky Bet
The decision to sign Carter through 2025 has led many to question the Cardinals’ long-term strategy. With James Conner already leading the backfield and younger prospects waiting for their shot, critics argue that Carter’s signing clogs the roster and diverts resources from more pressing needs, such as the offensive line and defensive secondary.
Some believe the Cardinals are betting on Carter’s upside, hoping he can revive his career in a more dynamic role. Others, however, view the move as a sign of front office desperation—a franchise scrambling to find answers after consecutive disappointing seasons.
Financial Implications
While the full financial details of the deal have not been disclosed, committing to Carter through 2025 suggests the Cardinals are investing more than just a depth piece. If the contract includes significant guarantees or incentives, it could limit Arizona’s flexibility in pursuing free agents or addressing other roster weaknesses.
This move also raises concerns about the team’s salary cap strategy. Allocating resources to a player with an inconsistent track record could backfire, especially if Carter fails to make a significant impact.
Fit Within the Cardinals’ Offense
Offensive coordinator Drew Petzing might envision Carter as a versatile weapon—capable of contributing as both a runner and a pass-catcher. Carter’s agility and vision could complement James Conner’s power-running style, offering a change-of-pace option.
However, questions remain about whether Carter can stay healthy and produce consistently. His history of injuries and inconsistent performance in New York casts doubt on his ability to thrive in Arizona’s system.
Fan and Analyst Reactions
The signing has been met with mixed reactions. Optimistic fans believe Carter could thrive with a fresh start, pointing to his collegiate success and flashes of brilliance in the NFL. Skeptics, however, see this as yet another questionable move by a front office that has struggled to build a competitive roster.
NFL analysts have also weighed in, with some suggesting that Carter’s potential could be unlocked in the right system, while others criticize the Cardinals for failing to prioritize more critical needs.
What This Means for the Cardinals’ Future
Ultimately, this signing could either be viewed as a savvy, low-risk investment or another misstep in a string of poor decisions by Arizona’s front office. If Carter can stay healthy and produce, he might prove his doubters wrong and become a key contributor.
But if he fails to live up to expectations, this move could further damage the Cardinals’ credibility as they attempt to rebuild.
One thing is certain: the pressure is now on Michael Carter to deliver, and on the Cardinals to justify this controversial decision.
Only time will tell if this gamble pays off—or becomes another costly mistake.